How to Find the Best Knife Sharpener

Looking for the best knife sharpener for your kitchen? Find all the best ones in this guide.

Looking for the best knife sharpener for your kitchen? Find all the best ones in this guide.

Everyone has knives in their kitchen, and those knives need constant sharpening to stay at their sharpest and get the job done right. Whether you’re new to the struggle of keeping knives sharp, or you’ve been battling with this issue for a while, you’ve come to the right place.

We’ve spent many years researching and trying to find the best kitchen knife sharpener. We’ve tried electric sharpeners, honing blades, and even the best sharpening stones. We’ve tried the best cheap knife sharpeners, as well as professional knife sharpeners. In the end it’s all about the ability to slice, chop and dice with ease in the kitchen and that requires proper knife maintenance and sharpening, which you can read about in depth here. We won’t go into the best practices for keeping knifes sharp, we’ll say that it’s incredibly important for good results from your knifes, especially if you’ve invested in a good knife set, that should last for many, many years with proper care.

Find the Best Knife Sharpener for You

Half the battle of keeping your knifes sharp is understanding the options and choosing the one that’s right for you. Since there are many different options, it’s difficult to tell you what is the best knife sharpener. You first need to decide which method you want to use. This guide will explain the pros and cons of the top knife sharpening options, and we’ll provide a chart of the best rated knife sharpener in each category.

How to choose a knife sharpening method

Each of the blade sharpening tools we’ll discuss here has its own pros and cons. In fact, each user is likely to find their own set of pros and cons with each method. There’s no right way for everyone. You want to look for the method that suits you best, whether it be a manual kitchen knife sharpener, a fully functional professional electric knife sharpener, or a sharpening stone. That said, some methods just produce a better result, thus we will focus on those methods.

Criteria for choosing the best home knife sharpener

  • Type of sharpening mechanism: There are two key factors that you should look for in a manual or electric knife sharpener.
    • First, the type of abrasive properties it has. Carbides can rough up the surface of your knifes and produce inconsistent results. Diamond, however, produces a strong, sharp blade. Sharpeners with diamond abrasive last longer and are of much higher quality.
    • Second is the type of sharpening chamber it has. Some create a better grip on the knife which allows for consistent contact with the blade. Wobbly chambers
  • Type of blades it sharpens: You’ll need to know your knives in order to determine the type of sharpener that’s best for you. Most techniques will easily sharpen straight-edge blades, but not all of them can handle angled knives, or 15-degree blades. Even less can handle serated edges or ceramic knives. After you see this extensive lesson on how to sharpen a serrated knife, you’ll probably want to find an electric knife sharpener that can sharpen serrated knives for you!
  • Learning curve: With any new tool or appliance, there will be a learning curve. Whether it’s that you’ve never used that tool before, or that this particular model is more difficult than others you’ve used, those are all considerations to make when deciding on the right kitchen knife sharpener for you.
  • Cleaning requirements: Each method has specific cleaning requirements, and some can certainly be more tedius and time consuming than others.
  • Does it damage the blade: When I first started sharpening my knives, I worried a lot about damaging the blade. A good sharpener won’t damage the blade and I’ll go even further to say that it should guide well so that a user cannot cause damage inadvertantly when using it. Many sharpeners come with different possible blade angles to produce the correct type of edge on different knife styles
  • Does it sharpen to your standards: Everyone has a different ideal for how sharp their knifes should be. I perfer to work with only the sharpest blades and I can easily tell when they are dulling. Some knife sharpeners acheive better results than others. If you want the sharpest blade, you’ll likely have to spend more to get it.
  • Space constraints: This is pretty self evident, but if you don’t have a lot of space in your kitchen for extra appliances, a small manual knife sharpener takes up much less space than an electric one does. Along the same lines, a professional electric sharpener will likely take up the most space.
  • Noise: There are a good many cheap knife sharpeners AND expensive ones that make a horrible amount of noise. The amount of noise they make doesn’t necessary relate to how well they’re sharpening, but it might sway you in another direction.

Types of Knife Sharpeners

Manual knife sharpeners

Manual sharpeners are generally very easy to learn how to use and they allow for a great degree of control when sharpening your knifes.   They also take up considerably less amount of space in your kitchen and don’t produce any loud, obnoxious noises. To use a manual knife sharpener, you pull the blade of your knife through the slot provided and work the blade back and forth along the … Manual sharpeners are generally quite a bit less expensive than electric sharpeners, they are lighter weight, smaller, and can be just as good at producing a sharp edge, when you apply the right pressure.

Electric knife sharpeners

An electric knife sharpener takes the manual labor out of sharpening a knife. Some think they can cause damage to your knives and can do no better in sharpening than using a good old fashioned stone, thus they aren’t a good idea, but if you choose the right electric knife sharpener, they can be a really great helper to many people how don’t want to learn how to use a stone, or just want to simplify the process. Electric knife sharpeners are larger than manual ones and they require the use of electricity, so they aren’t as portable either. But they do the work for you, thus requiring less precision and input on your part.

Wet Stone knife sharpeners

Some kitchen gurus swear by water stones for sharpening, saying they deliver very high quality sharpness, but using them takes a lot of practice and patience, until you’ve mastered the skill. I’ve never really gotten the hang of a wet stone sharpener, and I never really wanted to spend the time learning it properly. That makes me, and many other home cooks, not the perfect candidate for wet stone sharpening. However, if you have the patience and are willing to develop the skill required, it can be very effective and it won’t require buying a really expensive electric machine that itself requires maintenance and could breakdown.

Sharpening and honing rods

We’ve included the honing rod in our reviews because it is an integral part of keeping your knives sharp and the edge straight to enable ease of use in the kitchen. Honing your knives is different from sharpening them. A honing rod should be used in between sharpenings to keep the edge upright and cutting well. If you bought a knife set, it’s likely that it came with a steel honing rod. And it’s also likely that you have been under the impression that this tool is used for sharpening your knives, but it isn’t. Rods are meant to correct the shape of the edge of the blade. Over time, the knife’s edge can roll over, causing it to cut as if the blade is no longer sharp. Rather than needing to be sharpened again, the knife just needs to be honed, to return the edge to its perfectly aligned position. It is for this reason that a honing rod should be used on your knives more frequently than a sharpener.

Comparison chart of the best kitchen knife sharpeners

To help you find the top knife sharpeners for 2017, we’ve chosen our 8 favorite types of knife sharpeners from the overwhelming amount of kitchen knife sharpeners out there and we’ve listed all the key information from the reviewed knife sharpeners is in the comparison table below. You can sort the table by clicking on any of the column headings.

For me, the best test of a knife’s sharpness is how easily if can cut through the skin of a tomato, so that is the test we’ve held each of these products up to. How many times have you tried to cut through a tomato and realized your knives are not as sharp as you need them to be. You won’t have to deal with that problem any more once you’ve read our best kitchen knife sharpener reviews and decided on the best knife sharpener for you.

NAME
IMAGE
METHOD
ABRASIVE TYPE
15/20 degree angles?
OUR RATING (/5)
PRICE
AccuSharp 001 Knife Sharpener Manual – Basic Carbide N 4.5
Chef’s Choice 4643 ProntoPro Manual – Upgrade Diamond Y 5
Presto 08800 EverSharp Electric Knife Sharpener Electric – Basic  Sapphirite N 3
Chef’s Choice 15 Trizor XV EdgeSelect Electric Knife Sharpener Electric – Upgrade Diamond Y 4.5
Chef’s Choice 1520 AngleSelect Diamond Hone Knife Sharpener Electric – Upgrade Diamond Y 4.5
Chef’s Choice 151 Universal Electric Knife Sharpener Electric – Professional  Diamond Y 5
Messermeister 10″ Ceramic Rod / Sharpening Steel Honing Rod Ceramic Y 4.5
Wüsthof – 10″ Knife Sharpening Steel with Loop Honing Rod Steel Y 4
King Two Sided Sharpening Stone with Base Wet Stone Y 4

 

Best Manual Knife Sharpener Reviews

AccuSharp 001 Knife Sharpener

If you’re looking for a really easy to use and store knife sharpener, the AccuSharp 001 is a good choice. Although the abrasive wheels are diamond-honed tungsten carbide, rather than diamond, the AccuSharp produces a fairly sharp edge for your knives without the cost of a higher-end manual or electric sharpener. To use it, you just set your knife on a sturdy surface and run the AccuSharp over the blade with very light pressure. A few passes is all it needs to give new life to dull knives.

The AccuSharp isn’t just for kitchen knives. It’s designed to work with all kinds of sporting and outdoor knives, as well as serrated knives. You don’t have to worry about adjusting for the perfect angle. The AccuSharp tool guides the knife through the wheels to sharpen it properly. It can be used both right and left-handed.

Another benefit of the AccuSharp is easy cleaning. It can be washed with soap and water, or even put in the dishwasher, so maintenance is a breeze. Plus, it’s a handheld device that takes up very little space in a drawer. Overall, if you’re just looking to achieve a sharp edge quickly, the AccuSharp 001 will work for you. It’s an ultra portable knife sharpener that will get the job done for less.

PROS CONS
  • Easy to use
  • Inexpensive
  • Takes up very little space
  • Doesn’t sharpen as well as diamond
  • Can be dangerous to use

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the AccuSharp 001 Knife Sharpener

Chef’s Choice 4643 Manual Knife Sharpener

This manual knife sharpener is great for many different uses. Not only is it a fast and impressive way to sharpen your kitchen knives, it works for American, European and Japanese knives, as well as serrated knives and pocket knives. It has a three-stage system with criss-cross technology and 100% diamond abrasive wheels for the strongest, most exact edge. The sharpener also has bevel angle control for 15 and 20 degree edges, so you can be sure you’re getting the tightest grip, thus the best edge.

Two of the three slots on the Chef’s Choice 4643 are for sharpening – one for 15-degree angle blades (Japanese knives), the other for 20-degree angles (European/American knives). The third slot is for use with serrated knives and for honing, so you don’t have to use a separate steel honing rod to perfect the blade. There are other models of this sharpener available that will suit your needs better if you only have one type of knife to sharpen. For instance, if you’ll only be sharpening 20-degree angle knives, the Chef’s Choice 465 costs a bit less.

Overall, this Chef’s Choice knife sharpener is a great solution for kitchen knife sharpening. It’s light weight, easy to use, and offers the most features for the price. The sharpness you’ll achieve if you follow the Chef’s choices knife sharpener instructions is very good. Without spending quite a bit more for an electric sharpener, this is surely one of the best manual knife sharpeners for 2017. Cook’s Illustrated agrees!

Read our full review of this product.

PROS CONS
  • Uses diamond abrasive wheels
  • Works on both 15- and 20-degree knives
  • Higher priced than competitors

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Chef’s Choice 4643

Best Electric Knife Sharpener Reviews

Presto 08800 EverSharp Electric Knife Sharpener

The Presto 08800 is a basic, entry-level electric knife sharpener. If you’re new to the world of knife sharpening and looking to give new life to your dull knives, it will do the trick, but don’t expect a perfect edge every time. The Presto uses Sapphirite abrasives to sharpen in the first stage. It then has a second stage for honing. It is designed for standard kitchen knives made of alloy, carbon, or stainless steel, but does not work with Japanese or 15-degree angle knives. And it can sharpen one-edged serrated knives.

With the Presto, there’s no guess work. The blade guides lead the knife through each stage to produce the right angle. It will only take a few passes through stage one to achieve a fairly good result, and you may even find that passing it through too many times or using too much pressure can result in a duller result.  The honing process is necessary to smooth the final edge.

Though it won’t be as razor sharp as with some diamond-abrasive machines, the edge achieved with the Presto 08800 is decent for the price of this electric knife sharpener. If you’re looking for a higher-quality product, the 08810 professional-grade adds an additional stage to the process for fixing up even the dullest or nicked up knives.

Watch Presto’s informational video about the 08800

PROS CONS
  • Easy to use
  • Inexpensive
  • Doesn’t use diamond abrasives, which leads to knives with more “bite”
  • Not very powerful

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Presto 08800 EverSharp Electric Knife Sharpener

Chef’s Choice 15 Trizor XV EdgeSelect Electric Knife Sharpener

If you have a lot of high-quality kitchen knives and are looking to convert your 20’degree angled knives into 15-degree angles, the Chef’s Choice 15 Trizor XV is the electric knife sharpener for you. What sets this electric sharpener apart from others is its ability to convert typical 20-degree angled knives into 15-degree edges with precision.

The Chef’s Choice 15 can accommodate almost any knife, including American, European and Japanese knives, with both single and double bevel, converting them all to 15-degree edges. It has advanced, patented flexible spring guides to control the sharpening angle, so you don’t have to worry about adjusting it yourself.

It produces a burr-free triple-bevel fine edge with its 3-stage EdgeSelect process. The EdgeSelect system gives the user control over the type of edge they want to produce. By using stage 1 and 3, the blade will retain more “bite”, which is better suited for cutting through tougher things like thick-skinned produce. Using all 3 stages will result in a razor-sharp edge.

The system can also accommodate serrated knives, small paring knives and pocket knives.

If you like this knife sharpener for its ability to create and maintain 15-degree knives, but you’re looking for something a bit more powerful and professional, check out the Chef’s Choice 151 Universal Electric Knife Sharpener.

PROS CONS
  • Uses only 100% diamond abrasive
  • Produces a very high-quality, sharp edge
  • Cannot be used to maintain a 20-degree edge
  • Carefully following instructions is necessary

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Chef’s Choice 15 Trizor XV EdgeSelect Electric Knife Sharpener

Chef’s Choice 1520 AngleSelect Diamond Hone Knife Sharpener

Because we know that not everyone wishes to re-edge their knives to a 15-degree angle, we’ve included the Chef’s choice 1520 AngleSelect as an alternative to the Chef’s Choice 15 Trizor XV. The 1520 was esigned to sharpen Asian, European and American style knives to either a 15 or a 20 degree angle, depending on your preference.

The 1520 uses all diamond abrasives to create an ultra-sharp edge on your knives. It also has patented, flexible stropping and polishing discs that put a “gothic arch” edge on your knives. Read more about the gothic arch edge. The 1520 can also be used to restore damaged blades and can recreate the 15 or 20-degree edge on any knife.

Many different knives can be sharpened with this tool, including European/American blades, Japanese and Santuko blades, as well as sports, pocket and outdoor knives. Serrated knives are also supported on this electric knife sharpener. It’s a good choice for a high-end multi-purpose sharpener and is one of the top rated knife sharpeners for 2017.

The Chef’s Choice 1520 comes in both white and black models. Read our full review of this product.

PROS CONS
  • Uses only 100% diamond abrasive
  • Can be adjusted to work with 20 or 15-degree edges
  • Works on almost any knife
  • More expensive than other electric sharpeners
  • Difficult to use

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Chef’s Choice 1520 AngleSelect Diamond Hone Knife Sharpener

Best Sharpener Rod Reviews

Messermeister 10″ Ceramic Rod / Sharpening Steel

This Messermeister is made of ceramic which is very smooth. A ceramic rod should be used with most Asian knives that have more delicate blades and thinner edges. The ceramic rod provides a nice smooth finish on the knife’s knewly sharpened edge.

Although this particular ceramic sharpener is a 10″ rod, other sizes (including a 8″ and a 12″) are also available. You should purchase a rod that is about the same length or slightly longer than the knives you’ll be using to sharpen it with. This Messermeister rod had an argonimical grip and comes with a lifetime manufacturing warranty. Just be sure not to drop it, because the ceramic could shatter.

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Messermeister 10″ Ceramic Rod / Sharpening Steel

Wüsthof – 10″ Knife Sharpening Steel with Loop

Most of the sharpening rods that come with knife block sets are steel honing rods with grooves. In most cases, it is preferable to use a smoother steel rod, so it doesn’t scuff up the sharp edge too much. This Wüsthof sharpening steel is made from chromium plated steel with a hardness of 65° Rockwell has a fairly smooth surface so you don’t have to worry much about wearing down the blade. This 10″ steel rod is best used with knives that you’ll be using for tougher foods, like thick-skinned produce and meat, because of the micro-scuffing that will be added by the steel. It has a slip-resistant plastic handle and loop on the end so you can hang it on a hook in the kitchen.

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the Wüsthof 10″ Knife Sharpening Steel

Best Sharpening Stone Reviews

King Two Sided Sharpening Stone with Base

Assuming you’ve never used a whetstone to sharpen knives before, you should be aware that it takes practice and knowledge to get the right degree edge on the knife. We recommend watching a video on how to sharpen knives with a whetstone before deciding that this is the method for you. Here is an easy-to-follow video from https://youtu.be/nWJMEWck3WI on YouTube that will show you the basics of how to use a wetstone, like the two-sided sharpening stone we recommend below.

Our recommended sharpening stone is a two-sided whetstone from King. It is made in Japan and is a 1000 & 6000 grit combination stone. The 1000 grit side is used to sharpen and smooth the blade, while the 6000-grit side is used for honing the blade. These two grit levels are all you’ll need for sharpening basic kitchen knives. There are other grit levels that should be used for other types of knives, or for knives that are damaged and need restructuring. It comes with a plastic holder to keep the stone in place while sharpening.

See price buttonCheck price and read more reviews for the King Two Sided Sharpening Stone

Leave a Reply